How to Object to an MRA Tax Assessment in Malawi: The 30-Day Deadline
The short answer
In Malawi the first "objection" to a tax assessment is called an appeal to the Commissioner General. Under section 97 of the Taxation Act and rule 1 of its Eighth Schedule, you must deliver a written statement of your grounds to the Malawi Revenue Authority (MRA) within 30 days of the date the notice of assessment was dispatched. If the Commissioner General's written decision goes against you, you have 21 days to give notice of a further appeal to a Special Arbitrator and 42 days to lodge your grounds. From the Special Arbitrator, either side can go to the High Court on a point of law.
Through all of it, section 105 keeps the assessed tax payable "notwithstanding that an appeal against an assessment has been made", unless the Commissioner General directs otherwise. Pay what you accept, ask in writing for the disputed part to be held over, and do not treat the appeal as a reason to stop paying.
This guide walks through each stage with the section and rule numbers, because the time limits are short and the burden of proof is on you.
Before you start: the burden is yours
Section 95 says that in any appeal "the burden of proof that any amount is exempt from or not liable to income tax, or is subject to any deduction or allowance ... shall be upon the person claiming" it. The MRA does not have to prove the assessment right; you have to prove it wrong.
So assemble the file first: the notice of assessment and the date on it, the return you filed, the ledger, bank statements, payroll records and invoices behind each disputed figure, and your own computation of the tax you say is due. If you are an employee whose only income is PAYE, start with the payslip and the employer before the MRA (income tax and PAYE in Malawi, understanding your payslip).
Stage 1: appeal to the Commissioner General (30 days)
Section 97(1) lets a taxpayer aggrieved by an assessment, by a decision of the Commissioner General relating to an assessment, or by a determination of a reduction of tax, appeal to the Commissioner General "in the prescribed manner". The manner is in the Eighth Schedule:
- Rule 1: a written statement of grounds within 30 days. The statement must be delivered to the Commissioner General's office "within 30 days from the date when notice of the assessment ... was dispatched". The clock runs from dispatch, not receipt, which is why section 92(3) requires every notice of assessment to warn you of the 30 days.
- Rule 1 also allows an extension, before or after the 30 days expire, if the Commissioner General is "satisfied that reasonable grounds exist for delay". Ask in writing, with the reason, and attach the appeal itself to the request.
- Rules 2 and 3: attendance. The Commissioner General may require you to attend in person; if you fail to attend, the appeal may be decided in your absence.
- Rule 4: beyond that, the Commissioner General sets the procedure.
What to put in the statement: each disputed item on its own, with the figure the MRA used, the figure you say is right, the reason, the section of the Act you rely on and the document that proves it. Rule 6 later limits your grounds before the Special Arbitrator to the grounds in this statement unless the Arbitrator gives leave, so this is the document that defines the case.
Section 97(2) says the Commissioner General "may amend the assessment, decision or determination or disallow the appeal", "shall send to the appellant written notice of his decision", and must record any amendment in the assessment register. The Act sets no time limit for that decision. If nothing arrives, write and ask; the next clock does not start until the written notice does.
Where the assessment was raised by an administrative officer under delegated powers, section 100 sends the first appeal to that officer, with a further appeal to the Traditional Appeal Court for the district rather than to a Special Arbitrator.
Stage 2: pay, or ask for a direction (section 105)
Section 105 is blunt: "Notwithstanding that an appeal against an assessment has been made under section 97 the tax shall be paid as provided ... unless the Commissioner otherwise directs." The 2018 amendment re-enacted the rule unchanged, and added that where the Commissioner General believes the taxpayer may leave Malawi without settling, the whole tax can be demanded at once.
In practice:
- Pay the undisputed part on the due date.
- Ask the Commissioner General in writing to direct that the disputed part be held over pending the appeal. The Act gives the discretion; it does not oblige the MRA to use it. A request that pays the undisputed amount, quantifies the disputed amount precisely and attaches the appeal is the one most likely to succeed.
- If the appeal is settled in your favour, section 105 provides for the balance to be reconciled on notification of the settlement, and the assessment register is amended (sections 98(8) and 101(4)).
Unpaid assessed tax attracts the Act's late-payment consequences while the appeal runs, and a tax clearance certificate becomes harder to obtain. For a business, this is the stage that decides cash flow for the year (how much is VAT in Malawi for the VAT equivalent).
Stage 3: the Special Arbitrator (21 days, then 42 days)
If you are aggrieved by the Commissioner General's decision, section 98 gives a right of appeal to a Special Arbitrator, appointed by the President either generally or for the particular case. Part II of the Eighth Schedule sets the steps:
- Rule 5: notice of appeal within 21 days of the date of the written notice under section 97(2). It goes to the Commissioner General, in writing, stating your intention to appeal and your address for service.
- Rule 6: grounds of appeal within 42 days of the same date, lodged with the Commissioner General in duplicate. The rule is specific: in English, typescript, numbered paragraphs, setting out "the contentions of fact and the arguments in law" you will rely on. No ground outside your rule 1 statement is allowed without the Arbitrator's leave.
- Rule 7: the Commissioner General's reply within 42 days of receiving your grounds, lodged with the Special Arbitrator with your grounds, stating what is admitted and denied, and copied to you by registered post.
- Rule 8: notice of hearing from the Arbitrator to both parties.
- Rule 9: if a party does not appear, the Arbitrator may decide in their absence.
- Rule 10: representation. Either party may appear in person or by a legal practitioner. To be represented by anyone else, apply in writing at least 7 days before the hearing; the Arbitrator's decision on that is final.
- Rule 11: proceedings are in English; documents in other languages need a translation certified on oath.
The Special Arbitrator has the High Court's powers to summon witnesses and take evidence (section 98(2)), may sit with advisory assessors (98(3)), and must sit in private and protect the taxpayer's anonymity (98(4)). On the appeal the Arbitrator "may amend the assessment, decision or determination ... may refer the matter back to the Commissioner for further investigation, or may disallow the appeal" (98(5)), and gives a written judgment with findings of fact and decisions on law, available to both parties on application and payment of the prescribed fee (98(6)). Those findings of fact "shall be final and conclusive" (98(7)).
Stage 4: the High Court, on law only
Section 101 lets either party appeal from the Special Arbitrator (or a Traditional Appeal Court) to the High Court "on a point of law". The High Court may affirm, reverse or amend the decision on that point, give directions, send the matter back for further findings of fact, and make an order as to costs. Its proceedings are also private, with the taxpayer's anonymity preserved. Because facts are closed at the Arbitrator stage, the Arbitrator hearing is where the evidence has to be complete.
A worked timeline
Assume a notice of assessment is dispatched on 1 March.
| Deadline | Step | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| 31 March (30 days from dispatch) | Written statement of grounds delivered to the Commissioner General; request for a section 105 direction on the disputed amount | s.97, Eighth Schedule r.1; s.105 |
| due date on the notice | Undisputed tax paid | s.105 |
| no statutory limit | Commissioner General's written decision | s.97(2) |
| 21 days from that decision | Notice of intention to appeal to the Special Arbitrator, with address for service | r.5 |
| 42 days from that decision | Grounds of appeal lodged in duplicate | r.6 |
| 42 days after the MRA receives the grounds | Commissioner General's reply lodged with the Arbitrator | r.7 |
| as notified | Hearing | r.8 |
| after the written judgment | High Court appeal on a point of law, in the prescribed manner | s.101 |
Mistakes that lose otherwise good cases
- Counting 30 days from the day you opened the letter. Rule 1 counts from the date the notice was dispatched.
- Appealing by phone or at the counter. Rule 1 requires a written statement of grounds delivered to the Commissioner General's office. Keep a stamped copy.
- A one-line appeal. "The assessment is excessive" gives the Arbitrator nothing to work with later, and rule 6 freezes your grounds at this stage.
- Stopping payment. Section 105 keeps the tax payable unless the Commissioner General directs otherwise. Pay the undisputed part and ask for the direction.
- Missing the 21-day notice. Lodging grounds at day 40 without having given notice at day 21 is a defective appeal.
- Lodging grounds in the wrong form. Rule 6 is prescriptive: English, typescript, numbered paragraphs, in duplicate, with the facts and the law.
- Treating the Arbitrator hearing as a rehearsal. Findings of fact are final (section 98(7)); the High Court hears law only.
- Ignoring the current year. Provisional-tax and PAYE obligations for the current year continue regardless of the dispute.
Who this affects most
- Small businesses assessed on turnover or on estimated profits after a missed return.
- Employers assessed for under-deducted PAYE, where the argument is usually about which payments were taxable, including terminal benefits (severance pay and notice in Malawi).
- Individuals with rental or side income who filed a return and were assessed on a different figure.
- Anyone whose tax clearance is being withheld over an assessment they dispute: the appeal and the section 105 request are the tools, not a letter to the clearance desk.
Frequently asked questions
Is an "objection" different from an "appeal to the Commissioner General"? In Malawi's Taxation Act the first-stage challenge is called an appeal to the Commissioner General (section 97). Other countries call the same step an objection. It is the same thing: a written statement of grounds within 30 days.
How long does the MRA have to decide? The Act sets no time limit for the Commissioner General's decision under section 97(2). The 21-day and 42-day clocks for the next stage only start when the written decision is issued.
Do I have to pay before I appeal? Appealing is not conditional on payment, but section 105 keeps the tax payable despite the appeal unless the Commissioner General directs otherwise. Apply for that direction with the appeal.
Can I bring an accountant instead of a lawyer to the Special Arbitrator? Rule 10 lets you appear in person or through a legal practitioner as of right. Any other representative needs the Arbitrator's leave, applied for in writing at least 7 days before the hearing.
Can I raise a new argument at the Arbitrator or the High Court? Not without leave at the Arbitrator (rule 6), and the High Court hears points of law only (section 101). Put every ground in the rule 1 statement.
Are the hearings public? No. Sections 98(4) and 101(2) require the Special Arbitrator and the High Court to sit in private and protect the taxpayer's anonymity.
Have these rules changed recently? The appeal provisions (sections 95 to 101 and the Eighth Schedule) were not amended by the Taxation (Amendment) Acts of 2018, 2022 or December 2025 read for this guide; the 2018 Act re-enacted the pay-notwithstanding-appeal rule in section 105. Check the MRA's current notices for any later change.
Sources: Taxation Act, Chapter 41:01, sections 92, 95 to 101 and 105 and the Eighth Schedule (consolidated text as at 31 December 2014); Taxation (Amendment) Act, No. 28 of 2018, section 15; Taxation (Amendment) Act, No. 6 of 2022; Taxation (Amendment) (No. 2) Act, No. 36 of 2025. Statutory text checked 24 October 2026. General information, not legal or tax advice.